Children’s Booker Prize 2027 judge Lolly Adefope reflects on the challenge of reading 80 books in five months, and reveals how the books on the shortlist may be classics in the making
- Published
Children’s Booker Prize 2027 judge Sanchita Basu De Sarkar tells us why she believes voice and worldbuilding are so important in storytelling, and how reading The Secret Garden kickstarted a lifelong love of Gothic fiction
You will have read over 80 books in 5 months as a Children’s Booker Prize judge, which sounds like a dream job – and a slightly terrifying challenge! How have you approached this reading marathon, and what are your secrets to finding time to read when you’re busy?
I had such wonderful intentions. I collected a lot of advice: get up at 4am to read, don’t miss a day of reading, keep a spreadsheet. But I’m no good with 4am starts, and spreadsheets have always got the better of me. So instead, like a medieval anchoress, I did mainly shun society, and my Sundays particularly were devoted to books, in parks and cafes and every corner of our house, my phone battery deliberately on its last legs so I could only pick it up for something important. There was never a spare moment I wasn’t reading: train journeys (delays became a blessing!), queues, the pockets of minutes in between bookselling and unpacking boxes, waiting for the kettle to boil. Long lift rides. If I did venture out late, I’d come home and read till the early hours. And I found keeping a physical diary really helped with gathering my thoughts – and is now quite a nice keepsake of an incredible, ridiculously intense few months of reading.
Reading is often a solitary experience, but judging is a shared one. How does chatting about a book with your fellow judges change your thoughts on a story you’ve read?
I don’t know how people process books without talking about them! I’d finish a book and immediately want to dissect it with Frank and Lolly. Our regular meetings became the highlight of the experience, and I returned to many a book after listening to a particular perspective. And there’s also that magical moment when someone says: ‘Did anyone think…?’ and we’re all in agreement. ‘Yes! Absolutely!’
What are you most looking forward to about meeting the child judges for the prize?
Bonding over books. The more in our book club, the merrier!
Our regular meetings became the highlight of the experience, and I returned to many a book after listening to a particular perspective
What book made you fall in love with reading as a child? How and why did it capture your imagination?
The Secret Garden – I loved how stubborn Mary Lennox was, and I found the tale of a strange little girl from India slowly making friends and falling in love with flowers strangely relatable. With its dour uncles and creaky manor fixtures, it was also responsible for my never-ending love affair with Gothic fiction.
I also had a picture book that I loved to (literal) pieces – The Tough Princess by Martin Waddell and illustrated by Patrick Benson. A practical, bike-riding princess who wields a sword, decks her enemies, and isn’t particularly invested in romance. The storytelling was cheerfully outrageous, and no one can draw forests like Patrick Benson. It’s on my shelf (sellotaped within an inch of its life) to this day.
If you had to choose one character to be from a children’s book, who would it be, and why?
Bilbo Baggins. A character blessed with loads of food, luck, loyal friends – and he makes it back home in one piece and without any significant losses (silver spoons notwithstanding).
What are you looking for when reading books for this prize, and what makes a book difficult to put down for you? Is it the characters, the voice, the humour, the suspense – or something else entirely?
I’m drawn to the voice first, with the world and how quickly I inhabit it is a close second. We could be in space, in a school or on a dragon’s back, but I want to love being there. Then comes the plot.
Like a medieval anchoress, I did mainly shun society, and my Sundays particularly were devoted to books
What’s your all-time favourite Booker-nominated book and what makes it so special? Who would you recommend it to, and why?
Oh, I was never so thrilled as when Treacle Walker by Alan Garner was shortlisted. He is such a fine writer of fantasy and folklore; his books were a fundamental part of my childhood and it’s so rare to see fantasy on any shortlist. It’s an exquisite gem of a book; almost like a half-remembered song. I swallowed it in a single sitting, stared into the fireplace for a while, and then immediately reread it, this time stopping to write down my favourite lines. Then I yammered about the book all winter to anyone who would listen.
But also, Fingersmith by Sarah Waters is a book I have thought about once a week for 20 years, rereading periodically, and anyone who loves Victorian skulduggery, romance, and truly unforgettable women must let it into their lives.
Do you ever find yourself reading in unusual places to keep up with the prize schedule? What’s the weirdest – and most wonderful – place you’ve found yourself reading in recently?
A testament to stubbornness: reading on a rooftop while a church bell clanged on top of me for about 15 minutes. I kept thinking it would stop. It was eight in the evening, so too late for church, surely. Was the bellringer making up for a missed time? Were they working through something? It certainly gave my reading a sense of urgency.
There’s a rumour going round that snacks have been causing quite a stir in the judging room. Is there truth in this, and if so, what are your go-to reading snacks?
We had such fine ice cream up at The Reader in Liverpool on a scorching summer’s day while we discussed a tranche of books… I’m not sure any other snacks could live up to it!
And finally, tell us a fun fact about yourself.
I read Lord of the Rings approximately 60 times between the ages of 10 and 12. My least-requested party trick was reciting all 10 verses of the Lay of Lúthien.
